Elliott Associates has accused the London Metal Exchange of canceling thousands of nickel trades last year at the start of a court case that will decide whether a US hedge fund can seek $456 million in compensation.
The three-day trial at the Royal Courts of Justice in London seeks to determine whether the LME acted legally when it canceled billions of dollars worth of nickel trades on March 8 last year.
The landmark case will set a precedent that could have implications for other financial exchanges and London’s role as a commodity trading hub. This would also lay the groundwork for several other similar cases filed against the LME relating to its handling of the nickel market crisis.
The LME’s unusual decision to “wind back the clock” on nickel’s eight-hour trading on March 8 came after nickel prices rallied 270 percent in three trading days, creating a record intraday margin call in a single day on March 7 by almost 7 billion dollars.
The Financial Conduct Authority is also investigating the LME over the nickel market crisis, the FCA’s first enforcement investigation to date.
Elliott and market maker Jane Street Global Trading contend that the LME violated their rights by canceling nickel contracts, thus allegedly depriving them of their assets, and are seeking combined damages of $470 million.
Court documents published today show a chaotic and sometimes disjointed decision-making process inside the LME, as rising nickel prices – and related margin calls – threw the market into jeopardy.
The claimants allege that LME chief executive Matt Chamberlain failed to consult adequately with his own committees and market participants before making the decision to turn back the clock.
In its defence, the LME said that Chamberlain had consulted the senior leadership of the LME before his decision on the nickel trades, and that two dozen senior officials were unanimous in recommending the decision.
The LME says its actions on 8 March “prevented significant and systemic damage to the nickel market as well as other metals markets and wider-ranging derivatives markets”.
It added: “Under urgent and exceptional circumstances, the LME at all times acted in accordance with its rules and regulatory obligations and in the best interests of the market as a whole.”
Following this week’s trial, judges will determine whether the LME’s actions were valid. If they are found to be illegal, a second test will be conducted regarding the level of compensation.
Elliott also accused the LME of “protecting one group of market participants at the expense of another, by shielding LME members (or LME itself) from the risk of default,” according to a skeleton argument filed by lawyers acting on Elliott’s behalf. .
“The function of the LME is to allow trading between willing buyers and sellers; It does not include protecting market participants from the consequences of bad trading decisions,” Skeletor’s argument says.
The LME defense says the exchange was entitled to act objectively on system risk, and had a regulatory responsibility to ensure orderly trading.
LME lawyers are also expected to target hedge funds themselves in their arguments. “This case relates to the giving up of speculative profits to derivatives traders which they never actually received under a commercial arrangement,” reads the skeleton argument presented by LME’s lawyers.











