Season Ticket Renewal Time. Thirty-five years later, I can’t explain why I chose Arsenal. It was not the closest club (Crystal Palace) or the most successful (Liverpool). Once the decision was made, however, it became self-reinforcing. Attachment deepens with time and habit until they are near the point of origin.
I can tell, though not sure, which members of the political class follow team sports and who don’t. People who understand that Boris Johnson is actually Boris Johnson F.C. He has “fans” who joined long ago and for various reasons. For some it was Brexit. For others, it was something more important: his ability to win votes. Yet a third group hoped he would do something for the poorer areas of Britain.
But whatever the original allure, this has long been no longer the point. Once aboard, once attached to a man, he does not have to come down again. Some of his ego and even identity is now tied up with him. Such is the circular process of fantasy.
It should now be clear that Western populism, in the end, About this Too much. Don’t waste any more time rationalizing this as a reaction against inequality, “neoliberalism” and other things you yourself don’t like. If concrete grievances once motivated the movement, they replaced tribal sentiment as an end in itself.
Contrast this with what might be called (with journalistic rudeness) “eastern” populists. Whatever be said about it, Narendra Modi’s political project has some substance. So is the case with Viktor Orban, Vladimir Putin and Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. By this I mean that it is possible to imagine that these leaders might say or do something that alienates their supporters.
What will it take for Donald Trump to lose? What heresy? their clear support of covid-19 vaccines His cost is often less than that of his staunchly anti-vax following. Enthusiasts of the late Silvio Berlusconi have not given up on him even after he broke down or barely tried to keep his promises.
Ask yourself, had Johnson governed exactly like Rishi Sunak – same tax burden, same immigration numbers, same retention of EU laws – how much of his supporter base would have left him as a sellout? ? Nowhere close to considering Sunak as one. Johnson could light up £50 banknotes with Davidoff cigars, and even then the tabloids would hail him as a friend of the worker. So do, I’m afraid, a sizeable minority of voters. His club captain is his club captain, and that’s it.
To rationalize this crude tribalism is a folly, and yet it is done by people of the highest intelligence. Public discourse in the UK is filled with proposals to fix populism with the devolution of power, five-point development strategies for “red wall” towns, with the public and private sector working together with key stakeholders to bring about such I can deal with very real concerns. That’s kind of the McKinsey Global Institute’s view of how politics works. To be clear, some or all of these ideas are worthwhile on their own terms. The question is whether they no longer have anything to do with why people like Johnson.
In this summer of wall-to-wall Nadine cords of classified federal documents in chandeliered toilets, what stands out about Western populism is not its destructiveness (how much has the life of the average citizen changed?) but its emptiness. It turns out to be a huge, serious, pompous nothingness. And the voters who imposed it on the rest of the voters do not mind the betrayal. If Trump is the Republican presidential nominee in 2024, he must win more than 40 percent of the national vote. If Johnson faced the Conservative membership again, God help his opponent.
Back in 2016, some of us had to be preached about the need to “listen” to “legitimate complaints” against “broken capitalism.” Perhaps, at one level, populism was indeed a cry for a fairer economy. He passed some time ago. It is now a tribal sport.
In retrospect, Johnson and Trump should never have been lumped together with Putin and Erdoğan under the “strongman” tag. They converge on tactics – rule-breaking, institutional subversion – but the differences in substance are immeasurable. Eastern democracies are nationalist. If Westerners have -ism, it is nihilism.
And what a pity. Better chancellor than a fanatic. Better Johnson than Orban. Better, in the end, politics as a team sport is much more thoughtful than politics.
janan.ganesh@ft.com











