With a contact book full of teachers and parents desperate to give their children the best opportunity, tuition broker Elan is doing brisk business despite repeated closures, fines and continued government crackdown.
Two years after the government first cracked down on for-profit education companies, the business is “growing very fast,” said Allen, who asked not to use his Chinese name. “We have been informed several times. The authorities were reported but the punishment was too light.
“More and more parents realize that after-class training and tutoring still exists, and that their children will be left behind if they don’t use it,” said Broker, who lives in the Chinese city of Shenzhen.
Xi Jinping’s government has sought to reduce the benefits of money in a fiercely competitive educational environment, where a top university degree can be key to entry into high-paying industries.
The so-called “double reduction” policy in China aims to limit both homework and after-school tuition from 2021 and makes it illegal to teach core curriculum subjects such as Chinese, English and maths outside school for profit. However, in cities such as Shanghai, Shenzhen and Beijing, parents find a way.
The country’s profitable tutoring industry, once driven by US-listed Chinese corporations employing hundreds of thousands of people and valued in the billions of dollars, has splintered into a black market where agents and tutors are privately owned by parents. Keep in touch with father.
“For people in the middle class, they’ve found solutions — very localized solutions that are invisible to anyone from the outside,” said Julian Fischer, co-founder of Venture Education, a Beijing-based market intelligence consultancy. “It’s impossible to say how widespread it is because no one talks about it anymore.”
Serious pressure remains, as children may be forced to go down a vocational path based on middle-school test results. “Imagine the fear of God that pervades many families. , , said Fischer, who has spent the last 20-30 years escaping life in factories or farms.
The government has already published several notices this year, including an order to the State Council in March, that it will “continue to implement” the policy, but there is little understanding on the ground in major cities. The tutoring services she wants to ban are difficult. to use.
A parent in Shanghai whose child is in high school said, “Recently, I feel like things are back to the way they were before.” “But institutions are limited by rules, so they no longer exist.”
The government, the parents said, has clamped down on tuition “in the name of fairness”, but has “slowly turned a blind eye” to it as the underground market flourishes.
Tutoring services are nowadays often coordinated through groups on WeChat, China’s main social media platform, while tutors often teach students directly in their homes or work in centers that may hide their teaching materials in the event of an inspection. .
“Demand is absolutely insane,” said an English language teacher in Shanghai, adding that he earns about Rmb400 ($56) an hour from tuition and that the practice “usually happens” whenever he visits a student’s home. spreads”. housing complex.
“If someone sees you in the elevator, they say, ‘What are you doing here?’ You say ‘tuition’ and it’s like BOOM. ‘What are you doing next week?'”
The teacher also works in a center where any potential inspector “can tell during the day there’s a classroom” because “all our visas are up on the wall”.
“It’s something that’s always struck me as a little weird. It is illegal but they are certainly trying to operate legally,” he said. “I don’t really go in search of questions.”
The owner of a teaching institute in the wealthy eastern city of Hangzhou said teachers sometimes rent separate training venues to avoid detection, and online classes were also popular.
There is so much secrecy surrounding tuition that Fischer cited the example of a high-powered parent in Beijing who dropped off her child at a different location each time. Then the young man was taken to a mysterious teaching place that none of them had been told about.
As well as the practice it seeks to counteract, it is difficult to gauge popular attitudes towards the policy. Fischer suggests that parents would agree that the policy is a “good thing” because the previous position was “not sustainable”. Since it opened, they have seen more children playing after school at their Beijing campus.
The 2021 policy resonated internationally because of its role in eliminating part of the operations of major companies, highlighting the fragility of the private sector in an environment of highly centralized control.
For Xi Jinping’s government, the framework for action was designed to attract a domestic audience, but when it comes to enforcement, it is sometimes unclear where the government’s heart really lies.
In Shenzhen, Elaine is assured of periodic inspections by the authorities. “They have kids,” she said. “After coming to us for inspection, they sometimes come back later to try to find a teacher.”











