Get free US Supreme Court updates
we will send you one myFT Daily Digest Latest Email Rounding supreme court us News every morning.
The US Supreme Court has affirmed the power of state courts to review election rules set by state lawmakers, a case some feared would disrupt elections across the country.
In a 6-3 decision, the court Tuesday upheld a North Carolina Supreme Court ruling that struck down the state’s congressional map as unconstitutional propaganda intended to favor Republican candidates.
Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the majority opinion, which was supported by both liberal and conservative justices. The court’s three conservative justices, including Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, dissented.
North Carolina’s Republican-controlled legislature brought the case in an attempt to curb state courts’ oversight of election maps drawn by lawmakers, arguing that under the US Constitution, state lawmakers, not judges, decide elections. Mainly responsible for setting the rules.
This sparked a debate about the jurisdiction of state courts over federal elections, as the legislature urged the Supreme Court to set a precedent for giving state lawmakers broad authority over how to conduct federal elections.
Some critics warned that a sweeping decision in North Carolina’s favor would curb the courts’ power to ensure the validity of elections and leave state legislatures unruly.
The decision addressed controversy across the United States over state electoral maps and “gerrymandering”, in which political districts are drawn to benefit a particular party. It has historically been a fierce legal and political battle grappling with issues of race and voting rights.
In a brief talk with 19 senators, Democratic Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, who chairs the Senate Rules and Administration Committee that oversees federal elections, said she has “seen firsthand how state legislative efforts are making it difficult for people to vote.” tend to limit rights and limit opportunities.” Voting can threaten individual liberty, something the framers of the US Constitution feared.
In a brief statement supporting North Carolina, the Republican National Committee said: “The Constitution, along with federal statutes, already imposes a number of safeguards that would otherwise prevent the state legislature from overturning valid federal election results.”











