The consulting industry’s grip on Australia’s public sector is about to loosen significantly, as a tax leak scandal involving PwC has prompted the government to reverse a trend that has been denounced as ‘privatisation by stealth’ .
Australia’s consultancy sector has become the world’s fourth largest by revenue, behind only the US, the UK and Germany, according to The Australia Institute think-tank, dominated by the Big Four players PwC, Deloitte, EY and KPMG .
Its influence on government policy has been brought into sharp relief by the PwC scandal involving one of its partners, Peter-John Collins. He leaked to colleagues confidential information gathered during Treasury discussions in 2016 on the development of laws to prevent multinationals from tax avoidance, an act which PwC has admitted was a breach of trust placed in it.
“The right advice on tax law can be very useful,” said Max Bruce, accounting lecturer at the Australian National University, on the decision to bring in PwC for its expertise. “But judges and academics may be more suited to the development of tax laws rather than firms with obvious vested interests.”
Collins was banned from working as a tax agent for two years in February and the scandal began in May when the Senate published internal emails showing several PwC employees around the world discussing new business. was shown which was won based on the guidance provided by him. , with plans to win more as part of Project ‘North America’.
The ploy was spotted and stopped by the Australian tax authorities. He has argued that overturning the tax avoidance laws would cost the taxpayer A$180 million ($120 million) a year.
The case has provided ammunition for the Labor government as it downplays the influence and cost of consultants in favor of a stronger public service. “They can now go to the binary option — a larger public service versus these consultation issues,” Bruce said.
Government departments have now put a shadow ban on awarding new work to PwC. Some companies and a growing number of pension funds have followed suit. The pressure continues to build on the entire consulting industry since a new Senate investigation took place last week.
Deborah O’Neill, the former school teacher turned senator who released the emails, said the PwC scandal was only “the tip of the iceberg”. She highlighted issues such as the “revolving door” between government departments such as the Australian Taxation Office and the Big Four consultants, the use of legal professional privilege by consultants as well as non-disclosure of information such as client lists, which she compared to ” from the cloak”. Invisibility in Harry Potter”.
“It is the effect of contagion. It is like a disease and it will continue to spread,” said the senator.
Andy Schmulo, an associate professor at the University of Wollongong’s School of Law, said there was a strong temptation by profit-driven partnerships to misuse information when it was brought into the “inner sanctum” on issues such as tax law. He said he experienced pressure in his previous career as a consultant to show his colleagues drafts of confidential work he was doing. “It was like the Wild West,” he said.
The mood at PwC is grim, according to a partner working at the firm who did not want to be named, with dozens of colleagues looking to quit in the wake of the scandal. In recent weeks there has been anger over the way the case has been handled, much of it directed at PwC’s former management team. Tom Seymour, who was chief executive of PwC Australia, stepped down in May after admitting that he had received emails regarding confidential government information.
The effects are also being felt by the wider consulting industry as the Labor government begins to rebuild public sector expertise after decades of what Shamulo called “the slow privatization of the civil service by big consultants”.
Figures from the National Audit Office show federal government spending on consultants is set to reach A$888 million in the 2022 financial year, up from A$352 million in 2013. The Big Four consultants secured the bulk of the contracts over a nine-year period, and according to the NAO, totaled A$1.3bn.
But the situation is starting to change as labor cuts take hold, with government spending on key consultants and auditors reported to have more than halved year-on-year so far in 2023.
Steps have also been taken at the state level, with New South Wales, Australia’s largest state by population, on Thursday imposing a three-month ban on PwC from working on any tax-related contracts. Finance Minister Courtney Hughes said the move was a “proportionate response” given the investigation surrounding PwC.
Houses is a member of the state’s Labor government, which was elected in March and pledged to cut spending and use of outside consultants to free up funds for essential services.
PwC’s rivals also backed out when federal police were asked to investigate. Deloitte’s Australian leaders sent an internal email about the scandal, saying it was “deeply troubling and disappointing and justifiably attracting significant scrutiny and response”.
Andrew Yates, chief executive of KPMG in Australia, appeared before the Senate last week and described his rival’s actions as “clearly unethical and unacceptable” and “disturbing”. Yates defended his industry, which he said employed tens of thousands of people in Australia who had done nothing wrong.
The CEO said he was open to stronger regulatory oversight of the consulting industry and detailed his firm’s recent scandals. They include a contract with the state of New South Wales where its consultants were working with two different departments competing for the same tender, creating a conflict of interest. KPMG was also at the center of a storm in 2021 when it was revealed that 1,100 of its employees had cheated on exams to ensure that its consultants acted honestly.
The government has moved to strengthen the powers of the Tax Practitioners Board – the body that banned Collins in February – with measures such as a dedicated budget for the watchdog and closing loopholes exploited by the consulting industry. It has since said that it is open to further action as the fallout from the PwC scandal continues.
For some, it has provided an opportunity to expose “cross-contamination” between the industry’s auditing and consulting functions and to question the incentives for those motivated by financial gain at the expense of the public interest.
O’Neill said, “Those who put the love of money above integrity have had a field day.” “PwC traded its core values.”











