Get FREE Global Economy Updates
we will send you one myFT Daily Digest Latest Email Rounding Global Economy News every morning.
From time to time a “feel good” story pops up on American morning TV, causing most Europeans to spit out their tea in horror.
For example, Good Morning America, run a piece How about a “trendy coworker baby shower gift”: Donating some of your limited paid vacation to your pregnant coworker so she can spend some time with her newborn before returning to work. One woman said she was grateful to be able to spend a full 12 weeks with her baby before returning to her job, thanks to holidays donated by her co-workers. another tv station told the story Of the medical staff who donated their paid time off during the pandemic to a colleague with leukemia.
These are not one-times. about a quarter According to a survey by the American Society of Employers, American employers have a “Paid Time Off Donation Program”. a university, for Examplegives its employees the opportunity to “donate earned leave . . . to fellow employees who have experienced a catastrophic illness or injury and who have lost all accrued time off.”
People are donating their vacations to each other because the American system is so stingy in this regard. The United States has no statutory mandate for paid maternity leave or paid sick leave at the national level. It is hard to say how much it differs between rich countries. Average cross oecd countriesMothers are entitled to approximately 19 weeks of paid maternity leave. When I had my baby in the UK, I took almost a year off, most of which was paid.
Whenever I hear Europeans worry that their continent is falling behind America in terms of economic power, I think of disparities like these. Not that GDP doesn’t matter, but is it really the only yardstick on which countries should jealously compare their progress with each other?
This is hardly a new question. People have argued for decades that GDP is an inadequate measure of national prosperity or standard of living, but attempts to do anything better ultimately fail. Trouble is, once you start thinking about which factors are important, it’s hard to know when to stop. OECD’s better life index There are 11 different indicators. The UK Office for National Statistics hasn’t beaten it 44 pointers From participation in sports to the level of trust in government, to the “national good”. Before you know it, you’re looking at an awesome “dashboard” that’s chock full of interesting information, but makes it hard to tell what’s going on in the aggregate, how one country compares with another. If he does, forget about it.
It would be better to keep it simple. For my money, life expectancy is the single most important complementary measure of a country’s status. It’s a solid quantitative metric based on mortality, and few things matter more than life and death. It is also affected by other factors that people care about, such as the treatment of babies and mothers, quality of food, health care, education, pollution, jobs, and crime. One could argue that “healthy life expectancy”, a measure of the years people live in good health, would be even better, but the data available right now is too subjective to compare trends across countries.
Of course, policymakers already care about life expectancy. But what would the world look like if politicians compared these figures with the same passion and eagerness that they do with their GDP trends? By this measure, America would not be the envy of the rest of the rich world. Even as its economy grows, the life expectancy of its people tends to be even lower than that of its peers. In 1980, life expectancy in the US was roughly the same as that of Italy and France, and higher than that of Britain and Germany. By the 1990s it had reached the bottom of that group, and is now overtaken by much poorer countries in terms of per capita GDP. While all the ink has been spilled about when (or if) Chinese GDP will overtake America’s, Chinese life expectancy is already quietly on the rise. achieved that,
None of this is saying that GDP doesn’t matter. It represents the shape of the pie, which helps determine what a country can do in the world, as well as the kind of life it can provide for its people. It’s no surprise that GDP per capita and life expectancy are roughly correlated, but there are many exceptions from which lessons can be learned. Some countries punch above their economic weight when it comes to life expectancy, such as Spain, Italy and Japan with their healthy diets. America, with its guns, processed foods, and poor safety net, hits the bottom.
People who care about health and want to influence policy makers or the public often try to highlight its effect on the economy. “Ill health costs global GDP by 15 percent every year,” a McKinsey study Claim. “endemic poor health in “backward” neighborhoods of England costs the country about £30 billion a year as people are often too ill to work and die early” report suggests, But that’s to take things exactly backwards. We don’t want to live long and healthy life so that we can generate GDP, we want GDP so that we can live long and healthy life.
There is nothing wrong with a little healthy competition between countries. But when it comes to economic development, we should not confuse the means with the ends.
sarah.oconnor@ft.com
Get FREE Global Economy Updates
we will send you one myFT Daily Digest Latest Email Rounding Global Economy News every morning.
From time to time a “feel good” story pops up on American morning TV, causing most Europeans to spit out their tea in horror.
For example, Good Morning America, run a piece How about a “trendy coworker baby shower gift”: Donating some of your limited paid vacation to your pregnant coworker so she can spend some time with her newborn before returning to work. One woman said she was grateful to be able to spend a full 12 weeks with her baby before returning to her job, thanks to holidays donated by her co-workers. another tv station told the story Of the medical staff who donated their paid time off during the pandemic to a colleague with leukemia.
These are not one-times. about a quarter According to a survey by the American Society of Employers, American employers have a “Paid Time Off Donation Program”. a university, for Examplegives its employees the opportunity to “donate earned leave . . . to fellow employees who have experienced a catastrophic illness or injury and who have lost all accrued time off.”
People are donating their vacations to each other because the American system is so stingy in this regard. The United States has no statutory mandate for paid maternity leave or paid sick leave at the national level. It is hard to say how much it differs between rich countries. Average cross oecd countriesMothers are entitled to approximately 19 weeks of paid maternity leave. When I had my baby in the UK, I took almost a year off, most of which was paid.
Whenever I hear Europeans worry that their continent is falling behind America in terms of economic power, I think of disparities like these. Not that GDP doesn’t matter, but is it really the only yardstick on which countries should jealously compare their progress with each other?
This is hardly a new question. People have argued for decades that GDP is an inadequate measure of national prosperity or standard of living, but attempts to do anything better ultimately fail. Trouble is, once you start thinking about which factors are important, it’s hard to know when to stop. OECD’s better life index There are 11 different indicators. The UK Office for National Statistics hasn’t beaten it 44 pointers From participation in sports to the level of trust in government, to the “national good”. Before you know it, you’re looking at an awesome “dashboard” that’s chock full of interesting information, but makes it hard to tell what’s going on in the aggregate, how one country compares with another. If he does, forget about it.
It would be better to keep it simple. For my money, life expectancy is the single most important complementary measure of a country’s status. It’s a solid quantitative metric based on mortality, and few things matter more than life and death. It is also affected by other factors that people care about, such as the treatment of babies and mothers, quality of food, health care, education, pollution, jobs, and crime. One could argue that “healthy life expectancy”, a measure of the years people live in good health, would be even better, but the data available right now is too subjective to compare trends across countries.
Of course, policymakers already care about life expectancy. But what would the world look like if politicians compared these figures with the same passion and eagerness that they do with their GDP trends? By this measure, America would not be the envy of the rest of the rich world. Even as its economy grows, the life expectancy of its people tends to be even lower than that of its peers. In 1980, life expectancy in the US was roughly the same as that of Italy and France, and higher than that of Britain and Germany. By the 1990s it had reached the bottom of that group, and is now overtaken by much poorer countries in terms of per capita GDP. While all the ink has been spilled about when (or if) Chinese GDP will overtake America’s, Chinese life expectancy is already quietly on the rise. achieved that,
None of this is saying that GDP doesn’t matter. It represents the shape of the pie, which helps determine what a country can do in the world, as well as the kind of life it can provide for its people. It’s no surprise that GDP per capita and life expectancy are roughly correlated, but there are many exceptions from which lessons can be learned. Some countries punch above their economic weight when it comes to life expectancy, such as Spain, Italy and Japan with their healthy diets. America, with its guns, processed foods, and poor safety net, hits the bottom.
People who care about health and want to influence policy makers or the public often try to highlight its effect on the economy. “Ill health costs global GDP by 15 percent every year,” a McKinsey study Claim. “endemic poor health in “backward” neighborhoods of England costs the country about £30 billion a year as people are often too ill to work and die early” report suggests, But that’s to take things exactly backwards. We don’t want to live long and healthy life so that we can generate GDP, we want GDP so that we can live long and healthy life.
There is nothing wrong with a little healthy competition between countries. But when it comes to economic development, we should not confuse the means with the ends.
sarah.oconnor@ft.com











